'YOU HAVE THE WORDS OF ETERNAL LIFE!' IS PETER PRESENTED AS RETURNING THE KEYS OF THE KINGDOM TO JESUS IN JOHN 6:68?
Abstract
In John 6:68 Peter is presented as declaring, Lord, to whom shall we go? You have the words of eternal life! Whereas Jesus is portrayed as imbuing Peter (and his followers) with institutional authority following Peter's confession in Matthew 16:17-19-entrusting him (and them) with the Keys of the Kingdom, Peter is portrayed as affirming the sole authority of Jesus just prior to his confession in John 6:68-69. The parallels here could be incidental, but similarities between several aspects of the Matthean and Johannine traditions on matters of church organization and governance raise questions as to whether a dialectical set of exchanges might have been in play in the latter third of the first-century church. Such a possibility is analyzed by considering several crises in the Johannine situation, as informed by the Johannine Epistles and other evidence. Hermeneutical and ecumenical implications abound.
