Exploring the legal manoeuvres for an equilibrium between access to information and privacy rights in Kenya and South Africa
Abstract
An enforcement tension between the right of access to information and privacy is inevitable insofar as the foundation of one right is information disclosure, the other being control of disclosure. Both rights, however, are not absolute in nature and are subject to reasonable and justifiable limitations, allowing the intervention of international, regional and national laws to reconcile competing interests. The balancing of these rights in African legal frameworks is of key interest in Africa where the value of the right to privacy has been contested. However, the evolution of legal instruments such as the African Union Convention on Cyber Security and Personal Data Protection and the African Commission Declaration of Principles on Freedom of Expression and Access to Information in Africa is reflective of the legal adaptation to the contemporary needs of African societies on privacy and information. These instruments together with the Guidelines on Access to Information and Elections in Africa confront the challenges faced with the realisation of both access to information and right to privacy and data protection. This article focuses on the impact of this equilibrium in promoting good governance, transparency and accountability, including during elections, towards nurturing an informed and engaged electorate and public. In dissecting the domestication of the provisions in international and regional instruments, and national approaches to facilitating these rights, the article examines the legal systems in Kenya and South Africa. The article finds that a common anchoring consideration in balancing access to information and privacy rights is a public interest override that outweighs the envisioned harm.
