Home/South African Journal of Libraries and Information Science/Article Record
Peer-Reviewed Article January 9, 2011

Comparing Web of Science, Scopus and Google Scholar from an Environmental Sciences perspective

Are you an author of this work?Link to your sovereign AfriScholar profile
Published in: South African Journal of Libraries and Information Science
Publisher: Stellenbosch University • South Africa • 0256-8861 • 2304-8263
DOI: https://doi.org/10.7553/77-2-58

Abstract

This paper presents a macro-and micro-level comparison of the citation resources Web of Science (WOS), Scopus and Google Scholar (GS) for the environmental sciences scholarly journals in South Africa during [2004][2005][2006][2007][2008].The macro-level measuring instruments consisted of 26 evaluation criteria with the following broad categories: content, access, services, interface, searching, search results, cost, citation and analytical tools, and linking abilities.The micro-level measuring instrument's evaluation criteria represented the data fields of the journal records to establish comprehensivity.The macro-level evaluation results indicated that Scopus surpassed both WOS and GS whereas the micro-level evaluation results indicated that WOS surpassed both Scopus and GS.Based on the macro-and micro-level evaluation results the study was able to establish that GS is not yet a substitute but rather a supplementary citation resource for the fee-based WOS and/or Scopus for the South African international accredited scholarly environmental sciences journals during the period 2004-2008.

Download Full Text PDFView at PublisherCrossref RecordCrossref XML

Verified Citation Velocity

Recorded scholarly citations in African and international peer-reviewed literature

50
Total Citations

Citations are continuously tracked and harvested across continental OJS endpoints and OpenAlex feeds.