Home/African Journal of Range and Forage Science (AJRFS)/Article Record
Peer-Reviewed Article April 2, 2017

A global assessment of Holistic Planned Grazing™ compared with season-long, continuous grazing: meta-analysis findings

Are you an author of this work?Link to your sovereign AfriScholar profile
Published in: African Journal of Range and Forage Science (AJRFS)
Publisher: Taylor & Francis • South Africa • 1022-0119
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2989/10220119.2017.1358213

Abstract

It has been claimed that Holistic Planned Grazing™ (HPG), a type of rotational grazing, can increase productivity in rangelands and reverse climate change while doubling the stocking rate, mainly through the impact of densely bunched animals on primary production. Previous reviews have found similar or greater plant and animal production in continuous (season-long) compared with rotational grazing. Here season-long continuous grazing is compared with HPG alone to explore the evidence for animal impact. Three quantitative meta-analysis models were used to assess data sets from literature between 1972 and 2016. Weighted mean differences (effect sizes) between HPG and continuous grazing showed that there was no difference in plant basal cover, plant biomass and animal gain responses (p > 0.05). Thus, from the balance of studies, if animal impact is occurring during HPG, it has no effect on production. As interesting as the overall result is the significant between-study heterogeneity assessed using Cochran’s Q (p = 0.007 to <0.0001). Studies with positive effect sizes tended to have higher precipitation (p < 0.05), suggesting that only some rangelands have the resources to support HPG. Furthermore, there is scope for investigating the impact of HPG on socio-ecological aspects of rangelands, such as management.

Download Full Text PDFView at PublisherCrossref RecordCrossref XML

Verified Citation Velocity

Recorded scholarly citations in African and international peer-reviewed literature

84
Total Citations

Citations are continuously tracked and harvested across continental OJS endpoints and OpenAlex feeds.