The need for industrial policy coordination in the African Continental Free Trade Area
Abstract
On 21 March 2018, 44 of the 55 members of the African Union (AU) signed the African Continental Free Trade Area (AfCFTA) agreement.1 The agreement required members to remove tariffs from at least 90 percent of trade within the continent. The initial agreement was not signed by Benin, Botswana, Burundi, Eritrea, Guinea-Bissau, Lesotho, Namibia, Sierra Leone, South Africa and Nigeria. Although South African officials cited merely technical legal reasons for their failure to sign,2 the Nigerian president expressed fear that free trade might hurt domestic industries. In essence, the AfCFTA raises a number of issues usually associated with free trade: social cost, private adjustment cost and public adjustment cost.3 The aim of this briefing is to discuss the issue of industrial policy coordination in relation to the AfCFTA. In principle, the AfCFTA will aid industrial policy in countries with small markets by providing a large market, which is an essential component of successful industrial policies, according to Friedrich List and his followers.4 But as I shall show, regional integration in developing country regions often creates coordination problems, some of which impede effective industrial policy implementation. Trade policies are an essential part of industrial policy, and the movement of trade policies from the state level to the regional level (or in this case the continental level) should be accompanied by an equivalent movement of industrial policies (except in regions that have undergone industrialization); otherwise, coordination problems will arise and reduce the effectiveness of industrial policies. This briefing analyzes some of these problems in relation to African regional integration and then extrapolates to the continental scale via AfCFTA. In doing so, it shows why the inclusion of an institutional mechanism for policy coordination in the AfCFTA process is important.
