Home/Obiter/Article Record
Peer-Reviewed Article March 23, 2021

Cognitive Bias Affecting Decision-Making in the Legal Process

Are you an author of this work?Link to your sovereign AfriScholar profile
Published in: Obiter
Publisher: Nelson Mandela University • South Africa • 1682-5853 • 2709-555X
DOI: https://doi.org/10.17159/obiter.v41i4.10489

Abstract

Several empirical research studies have shown that cognitive bias can unconsciously distort inferences and interpretations made by judges either at the hearing, ruling or sentencing stage of a court trial and this may result in miscarriages of justice. This article examines how cognitive heuristics affects judicial decision-making with seven common manifestations of heuristics such as availability heuristics, confirmation bias, egocentric bias, anchoring, hindsight bias, framing and representativeness. This article contends that the different manifestations of heuristics pose a potentially serious risk to the quality and objectivity of any criminal case, despite the professional legal training and experience of judges and magistrates. Therefore, suggestions on how best to avoid and minimise the effects of cognitive heuristics, especially within South African courts are proffered. These include creating awareness raising, cross-examination and replacement.

Download Full Text PDFView at PublisherCrossref RecordCrossref XML

Verified Citation Velocity

Recorded scholarly citations in African and international peer-reviewed literature

23
Total Citations

Citations are continuously tracked and harvested across continental OJS endpoints and OpenAlex feeds.