Museums, archives and medical material in South Africa : some ethical considerations
Abstract
In South Africa, as elsewhere, museums, archives and other institutions often house large and growing quantities of medically-related records. This paper draws attention to some of the complex issues concerning these materials such as the process of collecting and accessioning the material into public, museum or archive collections. The paper also explores the legal situation of their status within these collections, the lack of appropriate national protocols and guidelines for access to and the use of medical records for research purposes, as well as some of the problems encountered by researchers and historians in using such material. Moreover, the current guidelines used by biomedical professional bodies are seldom of assistance. Some specific problems which need to be considered are elucidated as researchers and historians try to find a balance between the right to privacy and confidentiality on the one hand, and the right of access to information on the other. This challenge is becoming more pressing in the face of the new requirements of the Protection of Personal Information (POPI) Act. We conclude that it is imperative that new guidelines are drawn up regarding medical and related material and suggest that the South African Museums Association should take the initiative in this endeavour.
